PDA

View Full Version : Does "deceptively simple" mean something is simple or complex?


Cagey Drifter
04-24-2006, 11:41 AM
Every time I read the phrase "deceptively simple", I'm unsure what it means. Does it mean the object is simple or complex?

Cat Jones
04-24-2006, 11:45 AM
The phrase is usually used with a verb such as 'looks' or 'sounds' "It looks deceptively simple" means you think it would be simple to do the action or acheive the same result but in reality it would be difficult.

eg A professional makes blowing glass look deceptively simple.

Martian Bigfoot
04-24-2006, 11:45 AM
I suspect that this question is... deceptively simple. :dubious:

Colophon
04-24-2006, 12:05 PM
The phrase is usually used with a verb such as 'looks' or 'sounds' "It looks deceptively simple" means you think it would be simple to do the action or acheive the same result but in reality it would be difficult.

eg A professional makes blowing glass look deceptively simple.

Yep, that's the most common usage.

However, it can be used the other way round, to describe something which looks as if it would be tricky, but is actually... deceptively simple.

glee
04-24-2006, 01:23 PM
I always expect it will be in the context of a skilled professional making a tricky task look easy.

I remember a game show where hapless contestants watched an expert in action once, then tried to repeat the feat.
The best one was a woman from a bicycle company, who changed a tyre in 45 seconds. :eek: :confused: :cool:

grimpixie
04-24-2006, 03:33 PM
Having recently been inducted into the world of baby carriers and prams - the first thing that came to my mind is the folding mechanism of a modern pram. Somewhere there is a lever/knob/catch that needs to be flipped/pushed/released, and the whole thing folds away into a matchbox, but until you learn the trick (i.e. the first 147 times) it is impossible to work out. And yet, once you learn the trick, its a doddle.

Deceptively simple.

Grim

rowrrbazzle
04-24-2006, 03:46 PM
The phrase is usually used with a verb such as 'looks' or 'sounds' "It looks deceptively simple" means you think it would be simple to do the action or acheive the same result but in reality it would be difficult.

eg A professional makes blowing glass look deceptively simple.I disagree. The sentences "This looks simple, but isn't" and "This is deceptively simple" mean pretty much the same thing. So "looks deceptively simple" is redundant. The other alternative is an odd but literal interpretation meaning "At first glance it's simple, but as you look at it it's more complex, but further investigation shows you were right the first time." Or something like that.

Rigamarole
04-24-2006, 04:14 PM
I disagree. The sentences "This looks simple, but isn't" and "This is deceptively simple" mean pretty much the same thing. So "looks deceptively simple" is redundant. The other alternative is an odd but literal interpretation meaning "At first glance it's simple, but as you look at it it's more complex, but further investigation shows you were right the first time." Or something like that.

I disagree with your disagreement.

Saying "this is deceptively simple" is just not as clear in meaning as "this looks deceptively simple"

The former sounds authoritative - as if you are asserting that it is indeed simple, with a modifier on simple that just makes that assertion confusing, while the latter makes it clear that the deception is due to it appearing simple (this looks ... simple), with a modifier that explains that it is not, in fact, simple.

I think you're just making this whole thing deceptively difficult.

Gary T
04-24-2006, 04:24 PM
Some of the responses here refer to what I have always heard as making something look easy - not simple.

"Deceptively simple" refers to something which is indeed simple (not just looks or sounds simple), but which has an underlying complexity that isn't immediately obvious. An example would be the question "What is life?" It is a simple question. But it's deceptively simple in that the answer is not correspondingly simple, and can get tangled up in various complexities.

tomndebb
04-24-2006, 06:07 PM
I support Gary T. I have always understood the phrase to mean that the basics of an action or a question are, indeed, simple, but that the skill required or the meaning devceloped may require finesse beyond mere technique or understanding of a profound nature.

rowrrbazzle
04-25-2006, 02:56 PM
I think you're just making this whole thing deceptively difficult.I think you're just making this whole thing look deceptively difficult.

KidScruffy
04-25-2006, 04:33 PM
Every time I read the phrase "deceptively simple", I'm unsure what it means. Does it mean the object is simple or complex?

...and so another addition is made to my list of "phrases never to say for fear of confusing the issue"...

Back to the topic - I'd side with the view that "simple" refers to how the thing appears at first glance, although it's actually more complex.

--KidScruffy

HMS Irruncible
04-25-2006, 04:41 PM
"Deceptively simple" describes a thing that is actually and truly simple, and deceives the viewer as to the level of complexity of a different thing. Most often, the simple thing will be the appearance of, or container of, the complex thing.

For example... the appearance of an i-Pod is deceptively simple because in reality an i-Pod is a highly-engineered, complex piece of machinery. The technique of a glassblower looks deceptively simple but is actually quite complex and practice. The envelope containing my income tax return is deceptively simple because the contents are maddeningly complex.

AHunter3
04-25-2006, 05:20 PM
Nearly every post in this thread gives an example of the misuse of "deceptively simple"[/i].

An item that looks simple but is not isn't deceptively simple, it's deceptively complicated. (Or perhaps deceptively sophisticated, depending on how you're using "simple").

An example of something that truly is deceptively simple is the formula that generates the Mandelbrot set: z -> z^2 + c. You look at the incredible (apparent) complexity and beauty of the fractal and you do not think "oh, this is a graphical representation of a simple mathematical equation"; in fact, if you do not already know otherwise, you figure something like this must be generated by an amazingly sophisticated piece of source code incorporating bits of artificial intelligence and all kinds of context-dependent sensitivities and cascading clauses and whanot. But no, it is simple. Deceptively simple.


grimpixie's baby pram is an example of the deceptively complicated.

Rigamarole
04-25-2006, 05:31 PM
So the consensus is, nobody really agrees what "deceptively simple" means.

I think we should just stop being deceptive altogether and say what we really mean. ;)

Cagey Drifter
04-25-2006, 05:37 PM
Yeah, it seems like there is enough confusion about this to render the phrase useless.

ouryL
04-25-2006, 07:24 PM
Sometime that is deceptive is not what it seems, hence something deceptively simple is something that is not as simple as it seems.

gazpacho
04-25-2006, 07:35 PM
Sometime that is deceptive is not what it seems, hence something deceptively simple is something that is not as simple as it seems.Which does not answer the question of the meaning of the phrase. Does it appear simple but is actually complex or does it appear complex but is actually simple? Both cases something is not a simple as it seems.

HMS Irruncible
04-25-2006, 09:46 PM
Sometime that is deceptive is not what it seems, hence something deceptively simple is something that is not as simple as it seems.
That's not true. A deceptive thing may be exactly what it seems, but mislead you as to the nature of something else associated with it. Something that is "deceptively simple" is truly simple, but this simplicity may mislead the observer into making false assumptions about the complexity of other things associated with it.

My canonical example is the envelope your 1040 tax forms come in. The envelope is simple, and deceptively so, because it holds no clue as to the morass of complexity it holds within.

Key to this understanding: simple should not be equated with "easy", and the appearance of a thing should not be regarded as equivalent to the thing itself.

Ellis Aponte Jr.
04-26-2006, 03:04 AM
I concur with Brain Wreck. You wouldn't call a smart person with a dumb facial expression "deceptively stupid." But you might say they have a "deceptively dim-witted grin" or somesuch.

Sunrazor
04-26-2006, 10:02 AM
So the consensus is, nobody really agrees what "deceptively simple" means. I think we should just stop being deceptive altogether and say what we really mean.

We got into this discussion in a class on language pedagogy I took recently for my graduate work in English (we also spiritedly discussed the conundrum of reach exceeding grasp or vice-versa.) We came to the conclusion that most cliches are defined by the context in which they're used. If someone writes that glassblowing is deceptively simple, they will proceed to describe the process of glassblowing and let the reader decide what it means.

If you diagram the sentence, "Glassblowing is deceptively simple," "glassblowing" is the subject, "is" is the passive verb and "simple" is nothing more than an adjective describing "glassblowing." (There is no direct object.) Thus, glassblowing is simple. "Deceptively" is an adverb that further defines "simple," but doesn't change its definition; ergo, glassblowing is simple, and deceptively so. In theory, you should be able to drop the adverb without changing the meaning of the sentence.

Colophon is right -- it's one of those phrases that can mean two opposite things, depending on context.

HMS Irruncible
04-26-2006, 07:29 PM
If you diagram the sentence, "Glassblowing is deceptively simple," "glassblowing" is the subject, "is" is the passive verb and "simple" is nothing more than an adjective describing "glassblowing." (There is no direct object.) Thus, glassblowing is simple. "Deceptively" is an adverb that further defines "simple," but doesn't change its definition; ergo, glassblowing is simple, and deceptively so. In theory, you should be able to drop the adverb without changing the meaning of the sentence.
Precisely! If you say it's simple, it's simple, "deceptively" or otherwise. But if it's "deceptively" simple... it still is truly simple, but somehow the simplicity misleads the observer.

I'll go out on a limb and say that 9 times out of 10, when you say something "is deceptively simple", what you really mean is "its appearance is deceptively simple." Or some other superficial attribute of the thing is deceptively simple. Not the essence of the thing itself.

Best Topics: bilbo baggins speech hot box prison scrotal seam win surveys trucker bomb donald duck ride nyquil overdose suicide army 4f monopoly money colors laughing gas tanks buying sudafed online exercise bike resistance schneid definition am signal booster meijer sushi pool racking toilet drano product lamisil lotrimin 10th grade books hollywood diet walmart thumbing nose led zeppelin signs chloroform online pregnant fish name liar poker rules zipper stop replacement animation motors slang toss salad tylenol pm high duel truck driver banana alcohol fondas message board 3.5 baleful polymorph tammy faye bakker makeup how to keep robins from building a nest applying for a second job blow this pop stand song here comes the bride will drinking sour milk make you sick why do qtips feel so good spokane to missoula drive tick burrowed in skin good threats to scare someone jackie robinson cause of death everybody loves raymond house weird names to call your friends why do dogs cry in their sleep space heater carbon monoxide why was switzerland allowed to be neutral chicken gorgonzola pasta salad stick out like a sore thumb alternatives lose lose situation synonym what does a barrel extension do what is intercollegiate sport does soy sauce need to be refrigerated what to do if someone steals your prescription medication sistering floor joists code why do diesel engines last longer than gasoline engines pepe silvia with drums what to do with a dead cat at home do crushes ever work out kool aid on the go where steam games are stored the departed what was in the envelope why do people clink glasses