PDA

View Full Version : Why are there no banana-flavored Pop Tarts?


CairoCarol
08-04-2008, 10:51 PM
It seems like General Mills, or whoever is responsible for the culinary monstrosity that is the Pop Tart, will consider any flavor, however bizarre - a current hit appears to be "chocolate chip cookie dough," and in the past I've seen "s'mores" flavor.

And of course, regular fruit flavors abound - apple, cherry, blueberry, raspberry.

I can see why some fruits would not be candidates for a Pop Tart flavor - pears are too bland, citrus too tart (although "lemon meringue" sounds good in the unlikely event that I as an adult were ever to choose a Pop Tart flavor).

But bananas don't suffer from any of those drawbacks, so why no banana-flavored Pop Tart? Doesn't the American processed-food-eating public LIKE banana flavored stuff? That seems unlikely. Can food scientists not figure out how to create a stable banana-flavored filling? That also seems unlikely, given how low the standards are.

Q.E.D.
08-04-2008, 11:02 PM
I suspect it's because "toasted" and "banana" just don't go well together to the American palate.

Gary T
08-04-2008, 11:37 PM
Pop Tarts are, in essence, a variation of pie. By their nature, they lend themselves to a typical fruit pie (list of flavors mentioned above) but not to a cream pie. Somewhere along the way, the world determined that some flavors - e.g. orange, lemon, banana - don't work as typical fruit pies. They may work as cream pies, but that doesn't fly in a toaster. You want banana, get a cream pie. Don't toast it.

susan
08-05-2008, 12:06 AM
Because artificial banana flavors are disgusting? I'd eat lemon meringue, though, if I ate Pop Tarts.

Thudlow Boink
08-05-2008, 01:07 AM
General Mills, or whoever is responsible for the culinary monstrosity that is the Pop Tart :eek: Don't let Milton (http://youtube.com/watch?v=y-HfXBdzzWo) hear you say that! Pop-Tarts are made by Kellogg's. (http://wholepop.com/features/toasters/poptarts.htm)

gotpasswords
08-05-2008, 11:48 AM
Because artificial banana flavors are disgusting?
That would be my vote as well.

Not that any of the other Pop Tart flavors are much better, but flavor scientists have yet to make a decent synthetic banana flavor.

Koxinga
08-05-2008, 11:55 AM
I'm looking forward to Soylent Pop Tarts.

(Somebody ask me how they taste. Aw, c'mon, pleeze . . .)

Chimera
08-05-2008, 12:08 PM
I'm looking forward to Soylent Pop Tarts.

(Somebody ask me how they taste. Aw, c'mon, pleeze . . .)

It varies from person to person.

Koxinga
08-05-2008, 12:18 PM
:confused: No, I'm pretty sure they taste like mango.

MrSquishy
08-05-2008, 02:13 PM
Not that any of the other Pop Tart flavors are much better, but flavor scientists have yet to make a decent synthetic banana flavor.So apparently I'm not the only one who thinks so. As a little bit of a hijack, does anybody know why we can't seem to make an artificial banana flavour that actually tastes like bananas?

Hockey Monkey
08-05-2008, 02:23 PM
Artificial banana flavor is horrid. I imagine we don't have banana poptarts for the same reason we don't have banana jam. It would be like baby food in a crust. :blech:

Melkor28
08-05-2008, 04:55 PM
Origanly posted by: Gary T

e.g. orange, lemon, banana - don't work as typical fruit pies.

Execpt for the Hostess Lemon Fruit Pie, which is my favorite.

BrandonR
08-05-2008, 06:02 PM
I just don't think Americans like banana flavoring all that much. I had to buy banana-flavored Nesquik (http://britishcornershop.co.uk/britishfood.asp?id=DS0066) online overseas and have it imported because it was discontinued in the US due to poor sales. Plus, I really can't imagine a warm, toasted, banana-flavored Pop Tart as being all that good...

CairoCarol
08-06-2008, 04:07 AM
originally posted by Hockey Monkey:
I imagine we don't have banana poptarts for the same reason we don't have banana jam.

We have banana flavored jam here. I also have a number of recipes for it in my various cookbooks, some of which focus on island and Pacific cuisine. Banana jam is quite good (if you like sweet things), and needs no artificial flavors.

Of course, the bananas here are much more flavorful than the tasteless blobs sold in the US, so maybe the problem is less about whether a banana pop tart could possibly be good and more about whether there'd be any hope of marketing it successfully. (Though I still find that hard to believe - kids like bananas and they are the target market for Pop Tarts.)

Regarding artificial banana flavor, there was a SDMB thread on the subject of concentrated fruit flavorings a while ago, in which it was pointed out that most concentrated fruit flavorings that people dislike are in fact real - molecularly indistinguishable from the original product - and just reflect the fact that a really concentrated banana (or other) taste is yucky, not that it isn't the true taste of a banana. Most likely, it is.

Koxinga
08-06-2008, 04:44 AM
Regarding artificial banana flavor, there was a SDMB thread on the subject of concentrated fruit flavorings a while ago, in which it was pointed out that most concentrated fruit flavorings that people dislike are in fact real - molecularly indistinguishable from the original product - and just reflect the fact that a really concentrated banana (or other) taste is yucky, not that it isn't the true taste of a banana. Most likely, it is.

For me, it's the opposite. I like concentrated / artificial banana and hate the real thing, probably for the same reason.

Horatio Hellpop
08-06-2008, 05:23 AM
Bananas aren't fruits, they're herbs. This, according to an old girlfriend who worked for some banana retailer's association.

FoieGrasIsEvil
08-06-2008, 07:53 AM
Bananas aren't fruits, they're herbs. This, according to an old girlfriend who worked for some banana retailer's association.
She didn't used to date Donovan, did she?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mellow_Yellow
:)

HMS Irruncible
08-06-2008, 08:00 AM
Regarding artificial banana flavor, there was a SDMB thread on the subject of concentrated fruit flavorings a while ago, in which it was pointed out that most concentrated fruit flavorings that people dislike are in fact real - molecularly indistinguishable from the original product - and just reflect the fact that a really concentrated banana (or other) taste is yucky, not that it isn't the true taste of a banana. Most likely, it is.
Sometimes it is and sometimes it isn't. I believe that in the case of banana ester the flavor is identical, but flavor makes only a small overall contribution to "The Banana Experience", if you will. It's also about texture, sweetness, appearance, freshness, etc. These can't be distilled down in a chemical formula, so banana-flavored anything just isn't going to be as satisfying unless it's in some other combination that compliments the flavor or supplies those missing elements of satisfaction.

HMS Irruncible
08-06-2008, 08:12 AM
Bananas aren't fruits, they're herbs. This, according to an old girlfriend who worked for some banana retailer's association.
Not exactly true. Banana plants are herbaceous, meaning that they have green fleshy stems rather than wood ones. In fact, they're the world's largest herbaceous plants, if Wikipedia is to be believed. So it's correct to say that the banana plant is not a tree, it's an herb. But it's incorrect to say that bananas themselves aren't fruit.

Elendil's Heir
08-06-2008, 11:35 AM
It varies from person to person.

Like chicken, then?

kniz
08-06-2008, 12:51 PM
Of course, the bananas here are much more flavorful than the tasteless blobs sold in the US, ........

Regarding artificial banana flavor, there was a SDMB thread on the subject of concentrated fruit flavorings a while ago, in which it was pointed out that most concentrated fruit flavorings that people dislike are in fact real - molecularly indistinguishable from the original product - and just reflect the fact that a really concentrated banana (or other) taste is yucky, not that it isn't the true taste of a banana. Most likely, it is.

First off, I hope that the bananas you speak of are nothing like those in Jamaica.

Quite awhile back I read that research showed that youngsters today prefer artificial flavors over the real thing. I believe that strawberries were mentioned as an example.

BMalion
08-06-2008, 01:45 PM
Mary-Ann used to make the best banana pop-tarts, the Skipper and I loved 'em!

Best Topics: 4x grand strategy teenage mustache white numbing powder amerika meaning rammstein yoda jumping remastering music sublimes dalmation bake on paint european siren sparkeling wiggles picking nose hairs the critic theme long live jambi should meaning largest house number slave breeding bear vs lion instant patio system paul baxley windshield shade band youngest hookers vail vs keystone drinking straw diameter nonesuch mincemeat appropriate legislation pat phrase tens machine dangers waxing buttcrack oil for sandwiches serigraph lithograph whiteboard won't erase andy dick roast farmers mileage survey paintball reddit what does chi chi mean can jellyfish sting when dead does lectric shave work cartilage in ear hurts ambien 10mg not working where do celsius and fahrenheit meet tongue in cheek vs sarcasm when does the shield expire on hulu shoe stores like payless new kitten not eating was godzilla good or bad no human being is illegal sugar free gum no aspartame can i just switch sim cards between phones what can kill superman breastfeeding game of thrones stick on sunglasses film late growth spurt 22 can i still buy alcohol with an expired license brown sediment in toilet tank ankle hurts in the morning dulcolax time to work red bull vs starbucks doubleshot what kind of growth occurs when leaves and flowers grow to a set size? song with no chorus brake caliper guide pin bolt reheating chicken wings in oven how long do seiko solar watches last pain in the cartilage of my ear glasses lens scratch repair kit half wolf half chihuahua can you use drano in the toilet are black spots on cauliflower mold games related to cookie clicker how to make tonic water taste good opening garage door manually from outside