PDA

View Full Version : A fever is defined as a temp over 100.4--no matter what your baseline?


Ruffian
10-05-2009, 08:01 PM
Ugh. I have been fighting a thing for 10 days now. With the swine flu in the forefront of my doc's thoughts (especially since I'm 6mos pregnant), they were very preoccupied with my symptoms and temperature. By definition, I do not have a fever. When my OB checked me, my temp was 97.7--normal for me. Now that it has risen to 99.5 (standard "fever" for me), it's still not considered a fever as it hasn't crossed the 100.4 threshold.

I'm not much concerned--it's a bug I'll fight off--but I'm surprised that the doc said the standard is 100.4, regardless of the patient's normal baseline. (98.6 is an average, I know.)

In 15 years, my temperature has gone over 100 twice that I can recall for certain; there may have been a third. Even when I had pneumonia, my temperature never went above 99.5.

So--if "normal" body temperature of 98.6 is actually just an average, wouldn't 100.4 as a "normal" standard for fever be an average as well? I'm confused why one is considered flexible, and the other set in stone. Not that it matters all the much to me sickie-wise; the treatment is the same. I just found it odd.

Meanwhile, mmmmpppphhhh.

Hirka T'Bawa
10-05-2009, 09:40 PM
From what I learned in school...

There is a range for normal temperature, which depends both on the person, and where the temperature was taken. A fever is considered a temperature outside the range. Why that is, I don't know. However, here is the list of normal temperatures by site tested.


Rectal: 97.9F - 100.4F, Fever >100.4F
Oral: 95.9F - 99.5F. Fever >99.7F
Axillary (under arm): 94.5F - 99.2F, Fever >99.3F
Tympanic (Ear): 96.3F - 99.9F, Fever >100F


So, depending on where you are taking your temperature from, depends on what's considered a fever.

Hokkaido Brit
10-05-2009, 11:43 PM
This is something that drives me mad, too. I am a cold person it seems, with my underarm temperature being in the range of 35.8 (96-ish) to the low 36's. When my son and I went to the hospital (in rural Japan) five years ago with flu symptoms, his test came out positive and he got the Tamiflu etc. My temperature was 0.1 C below the "flu fever" threshold and my test came out negative. So despite being unable to actually sit up, I was told that "Flu is highly contagious so make sure to use barrier nursing methods when caring for your son." I was so frustrated that I just wept.

The same son was just diagnosed with Swine Flu (16 out of 34 kids in his class have it and over 60 in his school so it has closed for a week - eep!) and this time they were saying an axillary temperature of 38.5C (101 F) or more was indicative of flu. His temperature went up to 40.6 C (105F) taken under his arm on the second night of the flu. Really scary. The fever came on really fast though - two hours from his first saying he felt bad and his having a fever of about 100F to him having a temperature of 103F.

Koxinga
10-06-2009, 12:29 AM
Rectal: 97.9F - 100.4F, Fever >100.4F
Oral: 95.9F - 99.5F. Fever >99.7F
Axillary (under arm): 94.5F - 99.2F, Fever >99.3F
Tympanic (Ear): 96.3F - 99.9F, Fever >100F




A lot of public places around here have someone at the doorway ready to take your temperature with a device they put near your forehead. Usually not even *on* the forehead, but up to a centimeter away. What would be the temperature range for those?

BTW, I always found it very mildly amusing that 100.4 rule sounds like such a precise and finely tuned threshold, 'til you realize it's only the Fahrenheit version of a fat rounded off number in Centigrade ((100.4 -32) * 5/9 = 38)

Superhal
10-06-2009, 04:35 AM
Honestly, this just pisses me off.

If my "normal" temperature is X, X-.1 or X +.1 should not be considered unusual.

However, when I go to a doctor, and they check my temp, and decide I do/don't have a fever, I remind them that I need 9-10 hours of sleep vs the "normal" 8 hours. Also, that one particular front tooth is the 3rd vs the canonical 2.

I'm sick, I know it, and they should not shunt me as an aside just because I do not reflect "the average."

Bravo Romeo
10-06-2009, 06:15 AM
Maybe the definition of fever at that temperature comes from a temperature at which it is known that enzymes may start to denature? We all have the same enzymes which would explain why a "fever" is defined at a specific temperature. Just a guess.

dracoi
10-06-2009, 02:27 PM
Maybe the definition of fever at that temperature comes from a temperature at which it is known that enzymes may start to denature? We all have the same enzymes which would explain why a "fever" is defined at a specific temperature. Just a guess.

This is more along the lines that medical pros use, I think. The relative difference in temperature might measure how sick you are, but actual damage that would be life threatening is really based on the actual temperature, not a relative difference. Putting someone in an ice bath to cool them down doesn't make them less sick, but it does make them less hot and can save their life.

Part of the problem with comparing a fever to a baseline is that the doctor rarely knows the baseline and patients can't always be trusted. Even if the patients charts their temp every day, does the doctor know whether they're taking it correctly, with an accurate thermometer?

I think a survey showed that something like 80% of people believe they heal more quickly than average. Clearly, at least 30% of us are optimists who really don't know what we're talking about.

redtail23
10-06-2009, 02:43 PM
I think part of it depends on your doc & your relationship with em.

I have two people in my family that normally run low temperatures. Both have discussed this with their docs, & the docs will take that into account when they have a fever. They do have to remind the docs every time, but it does get considered after that.

Even more fun are the members of my family who often run "reverse fever". That is, when they get sick and feel feverish, their temps often drop rather than rise. It's the weirdest thing.

Best Topics: planet fitness bullshit gusset panties cordura wallet yoshi definition the rapist british quid mc nomad bratfree forum fat elvis pic piers anthony firefly stolen newspapers cornmeal ants girl friday origin naacp funding sources rodger wilco the simpsons thanksgiving marking territory humans ambassador mollari caseless rounds car 28 ruben meat a teddy clothing dog bite glove tommy kirk imdb neighbor cock oslo vs copenhagen is megashare illegal loomis halloween sudafed expiration provo utah people nigerien pronunciation dear sir madame past your prime did jesus have a middle name man who sold the world lyrics meaning cottonelle vs quilted northern what cause sneezing attacks gluing rubber to plastic 5w 20 vs 5w 30 how to keep pizza warm in oven it's better to keep silent and be thought a fool vanilla extract in paint can rabbits and cats breed how to get rid of mice in your car doctor called after blood test how hard is the skull countries ending in ia what to do about a dry nose buy cars from police auction yellow speed limit sign other names for fibromyalgia running shorts as swim trunks how to control your facial expressions john wayne on horse paypal credit card cash advance or purchase chains of love erasure oldest high school student dry counties in ohio can't see printer on network alpha phi alpha ritual revealed books on how to manipulate people ive said my peace mazda 3 headlight retention clip are you there, moriarty? does basketball have quarters