Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes
#1
Old 11-07-2002, 06:08 PM
Guest
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 3
Why Metal Objects Feel Colder Than Wood Ones?

https://academicpursuits.us/classics/a1_117b.html

Thermal conductivity is only one reason why metal surfaces feel colder than wood surfaces. There is another equally important effect at play, which Cecil omits to mention. Wood has
a very low heat capacity compared to metal objects.

When you touch an object that is at room temperature, heat flows from your hand to the object,
which warms the object's surface. This is a transient heat transfer problem. Transient conduction
heat transfer depends on BOTH heat capacity and conductivity. Heat Capacity is the product of density times specific heat.

The instantaneous heat transfer from your hand depends upon capacity of the object to absorb heat, as well as the object's thermal conductivity. If you were to touch two surfaces with the same conductivity, the object with the higher heat capacity (density x specific heat) would feel
colder. Heat would flow at a greater rate from your hand into the surface.

The proof is simple. Think about plunging your hand into a sink of water that is at room temperature. It feels very cold. Water has a high heat capacity, but relatively low thermal conductivity (about 250 times lower than aluminum).

In fact, analysis (lots of calculus) shows that instantaneous heat flux (and hence, the intensity of the cold sensation) is roughly proportional to square root of heat capacity. In comparison, the
instantaneous heat flow also depends upon the square root conductivity.

So, heat capacity has just as much effect as the thermal conductivity on the sensation of cold you
feel when you touch a metal surface.

Heat Transfer Guy
#2
Old 11-07-2002, 08:03 PM
Guest
Join Date: Aug 1999
Location: 23 male, Boston
Posts: 5,791
You know, the name Heat Transfer Guy sounds to me like a great name for a superhero. But I get the feeling he'd be in league with the evil Dr. Entropy.
#3
Old 11-08-2002, 03:35 PM
Guest
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 3

More knowledgeable about the thermodynamic power of locomotives,
Able to calculate the cooling capacity for tall buildings...

Look! Up in the Sky.... Its Heat Transfer Guy
#4
Old 11-13-2002, 01:19 PM
zut zut is offline
Charter Member
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: Detroit, MI
Posts: 3,725
Well, yes and no, Heat Transfer Guy. Some numbers would help to compare magnitudes of these properties. From my Mark's Standard Handbook for Mechanical Engineers and Mechanical Engineer's Reference Manual:

Aluminum:
density = 2732 kg/m3
specific heat = 0.481 kJ/(kg*K)
heat capacity = 1314 kJ/(m3*K)
thermal conductivity = 117 Btu/(hr*ft*F)

Iron:
density = 7900 kg/m3
specific heat = .216 kJ/(kg*K)
heat capacity = 1706 kJ/(m3*K)
thermal conductivity = 36 Btu/(hr*ft*F)

Wood:
density = 400-700 kg/m3
specific heat = 2.4 - 2.8 kJ/(kg*K)
heat capacity = 1120 - 1680 kJ/(m3*K)
thermal conductivity = 0.06-0.20 Btu/(hr*ft*F)

Water:
density = 1000 kg/m3
specific heat = 4.177 kJ/(kg*K)
heat capacity = 4177 kJ/(m3*K)
thermal conductivity = 0.319 Btu/(hr*ft*F)

(sorry about mixing units)

Now, as Cecil said, the thermal conductivity of metals (aluminum and iron, in the examples above) is much greater than that of wood: the difference is about three orders of magnitude. The heat capacity for metals and woods, however, is basically the same. That doesn't make what you said wrong, because the heat capacity of a material is extremely important in how cold it will feel. It's just that, in comparing wood and metal, the heat capacity is not all that much different.

Additionally, I think your analogy using a sink full of water is flawed. Water does have a high heat capacity and relatively low thermal conductivity; however, the numbers are not hugely different from wood. What you're overlooking is that, in water, heat can convect away from your hand, so that the actual "heat removal rate" is much larger than the thermal conductivity would imply.
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:36 PM.

Copyright © 2017
Best Topics: circular farming callsign actual widower ring finger dented rim repair bacardi nutrition smell of sex testicle weight bon oui futurama washer balls msn opens randomly watery quiche teardrops house chips vs fries navy mm3 definition of punta cab over pete hdmi frequency housewarming plant viagra cost walmart mexican jacket name aflac wiki french vs catalina oblivion ugly faces pp pages game world sizes a4v success heart rate 170 fatherland germany hemicorporectomy bucket bleach and aluminum tpms rebuild digital audio cable orange best way to heat up sake key wont go into car door lock ohio license plate sticker placement aluminum free antiperspirant for men bug bites under clothing american express only has 15 numbers all fire alarms going off ramanujan good will hunting what does gorda mean in spanish best way to send cash in the mail why cant you drink grapefruit juice with xanax how to put cat to sleep nf 925 thailand ring how much is a shilling worth in 1800 can an owl carry off a cat do cats have penises star moving across the sky they should've sent a poet what does it mean when a pig wags its tail car blocked in parking lot refusing to shake someone's hand sales tax on out of state purchases 76 gas station logo how much blood is taken in a blood test where can i buy ddt pesticide how to burn audible book to cd how long can lizards go without eating how long to reset alcohol tolerance suicide by stabbing yourself in the heart sprint pcs or nextel how many is a gazillion