Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes
#1
Old 10-16-2004, 11:23 PM
Guest
Join Date: Sep 2003
Location: 37.7 Lat, -89.2 Long IL
Posts: 510
Question about electrolytes and alcohol - bad combo? possible urban legend

I did a few searches on snopes but didn't come up with anything.

A friend told me that he knows someone who goes to school in Nashville TN where this story took place.

There was a girl who was studying to finals. To stay awake and aware she constantly drank gatorade and other energy drinks that contained electrolytes for about a week. After her last final on friday she went out to the bars and parties to forget about her stressful week. She drank a LOT. She went to bed that night and woke up still feeling quite drunk. In fact, she felt intoxicated for the next few days without drinking another drop of alcohol.

As the story goes, she had so many electrolytes in her body that they held the alcohol in and in turn kept her drunk for days.

Possible? Lies? Could this possibly be true or just another Urban Legend? I'm skeptical.
#2
Old 10-17-2004, 01:21 AM
Guest
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 987
It sounds like an urban legend, particularly because it contains a moral lesson about bad things that will happen to you if you drink too much.

If you drink excessive amounts of electrolytes, they will be excreted by the kidneys (unless, of course, there's a problem with your kidneys). Maintaining the correct balance of electrolytes is essential, and serious problems including death can result from electrolyte imbalances. But the kidneys can maintain this balance well, or you could easily die from eating too much salt.

I can't see how consuming excessive amounts of electrolytes could cause prolonged intoxication, even if the electrolytes weren't excreted by the kidneys. Alcohol is metabolized in the liver to acetaldehyde, then to acetic acid. The acetic acid is then 'burned' for energy in the same way that the body obtains energy from carbohydrates -- except that it enters the process at a later stage than carbohydrates. Some alcohol is excreted through the kidneys, but that's not the main way it's eliminated. This page discusses alcohol metabolism and briefly discusses how excessive alcohol consumption can cause lowered electrolyte levels. (If anything, maybe having high amounts of electrolytes would be helpful.)

One other problem is that the story seems to confuse 'sports drink' with 'energy drink'. Gatorade is a sports drink, a solution that is meant to replace the electrolytes that athletes lose from heavy sweating. Sports drinks contain carbohydrates to provide chemical energy, such as one would need for strenuous exercise. Neither electrolytes nor carbohydrates provide the sort of 'energy' that promotes wakefulness. To stay awake through finals, a student would need a drink that contained a stimulant such as caffeine, not a drink that contained electrolytes. And caffeine, incidentally, is diuretic and would assist in the elimination of excessive electrolytes.
#3
Old 10-17-2004, 01:47 AM
Guest
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: East Lansing, MI
Posts: 2,687
Bullshit I say. Simple solution for being drunk: time will heal. 100% of all doctors I have ever known agree.
#4
Old 10-17-2004, 06:31 PM
Guest
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Cocytus
Posts: 275
taking in a lot af salt before drinking is just like eating the bowlful of pretzels at the bar.

also, i thought the salt loss from sweating wasn't a major factor and that the salt in gatorade is just to make you thirsty so you drink enough water and don't get dehydrated.
#5
Old 10-17-2004, 06:52 PM
Guest
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: A Derby City lab
Posts: 1,292
This kinda sounds parallel to the good old "toxin buildup" that can be cured by plunking down $100 for some bogus system cleanser (and the accompanying fast or odd food consumption): What you eat or drink stays in and has to be flushed out somehow. The whole point behind urine production is to maintain water and salt balance in the blood, and unless this girl had bad or failed kidneys, she would have exctreted whatever was in excess, be it water or salts. I also don't see how electrolytes can hold alcohol in your system. That just doesn't happen. I think the moral of the story is that after trying to take care of herself with more or less healthy drinks, she goes out and poisons herself with alcohol, and it has a worse effect on her than usual (as punishment for not taking care of herself).

Vlad/Igor
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:32 PM.

Copyright © 2017
Best Topics: 3 stepper snake arnold height mike briggs obituary coyote deterrent tapering off heroin immediate rem sleep creative bet ideas mash 8063 mailbox flag up asd urban dictionary polecat vs ferret buttered pop tart honey bee vomit mooks nyc acetylene lighting pompatus define witches hat playground bass noise complaint slave relationships dog viagra south park moses tingly nose tip lung damage board mulders dad sliding weight scale arrow fletching feathers pidgeon poison cthulu pronunciation popeye jingle lyrics drinking water heaters knave card sammy davis jr satanist how hard is java to learn how much algebra is in calculus britney spears bacon number how many chicken breasts is a pound growing jasmine from seed liquid versus powder dishwasher detergent 3/4 floating axle best mouse poison safe for pets set up auto pay bank of america credit card courage the cowardly dog gerbil what is an ed.d degree y tu mama tambien soundtrack songs pill stuck in chest burning once upon a time in mexico shoot the cook nursing pinning ceremony gift ideas pop songs in waltz time how to pronounce corp is chocolate and cocaine from the same plant substitute for cream in coffee crab dead mans fingers rubber mallet vs dead blow hammer what is a parenting class how long is spaghetti good for in the refrigerator how many teats does a goat have storing gas in garage medication for runny nose do nhl teams have their own planes car parked in front of my driveway do you put detergent in before or after clothes replacement vinyl siding pieces how to warm up a pool without a heater