Reply
Thread Tools Display Modes
#1
Old 12-29-2017, 11:16 PM
Guest
Join Date: Oct 2008
Location: San Jose, CA
Posts: 3,802
State Tax return in 2018

At present 2017 I can deduct all state and local taxes paid in 2017. But in 2018 the deduction is capped at $10,000.
Presently if I use a Schedule A and deduct my state income tax, and get a state tax return then I have to declare the return as income. Example If in 2017 I deducted $2,000 for my 2016 taxes and then get a state return of $500 in 2017. When I fill out my 2017 tax forms I have to declare the $500 as income.


What will happen for 2018 tax year. Assume my state and local taxes total $11,000. My state income tax is $3,000. When I fill out my state tax forms I get a $1,000 return. I receive the return check in 2019. When I fill out my 2019 tax form will the full state return be taxable.

If so I either need to adjust my state tax deductions from so I do not get a return from the state, or pay my next property tax in the next two days to lower my combined state and local taxes for 2018.
__________________
Old Snipes do not die they just loose their steam
#2
Old 12-30-2017, 12:27 AM
Member
Join Date: Sep 2000
Posts: 7,619
Quote:
Originally Posted by Snnipe 70E View Post
At present 2017 I can deduct all state and local taxes paid in 2017. But in 2018 the deduction is capped at $10,000.
Presently if I use a Schedule A and deduct my state income tax, and get a state tax return then I have to declare the return as income. Example If in 2017 I deducted $2,000 for my 2016 taxes and then get a state return of $500 in 2017. When I fill out my 2017 tax forms I have to declare the $500 as income.


What will happen for 2018 tax year. Assume my state and local taxes total $11,000. My state income tax is $3,000. When I fill out my state tax forms I get a $1,000 return. I receive the return check in 2019. When I fill out my 2019 tax form will the full state return be taxable.

If so I either need to adjust my state tax deductions from so I do not get a return from the state, or pay my next property tax in the next two days to lower my combined state and local taxes for 2018.
The current law is that state income tax refunds are taxible only to the extent they were deducted in the previous year. I presume that hasn't changed.

So currently you declare the $500 refund as income because you deducted it the previous year.

If in 2019 you get a $1000 refund, but you did not deduct it in 2018, because it was over the $10000 max for SALT deductions or because you didn't itemize, then it is not taxable.
#3
Old 12-30-2017, 03:37 AM
Guest
Join Date: Feb 2011
Posts: 3,806
The current law is that state refunds are taxable to the extent that you had a net tax benefit from them in the previous year.

For example, for 2017 the standard deduction for a single taxpayer is $6350. Let's say that you had $2000 in state income tax deductions and $5350 in other deductions, for a total of $7350. In 2018, you get a state income tax refund of $1500. Only $1000 would be taxable in 2018. Why? Because your deductions only came to $1000 over what the standard deduction would have been. Since you could have taken the standard deduction, the remaining $500 of your refund provided you with no net tax benefit.

I don't know of anything that has changed the net tax benefit rule.

So, in the example you gave in your post, you would have gotten no net tax benefit from the $1000 that was refunded, so it shouldn't be taxable.
#4
Old 12-30-2017, 07:16 PM
Guest
Join Date: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,740
Alley Dweller hit on the key point: the tax benefit rule. This is the key to determining if any refund you receive is taxable income. It's only income if you deducted the outlay of cash on a previous return and the deduction reduced your tax liability or changed other tax attributes such as carryovers in your favor. In order to determine this, you look at what your tax return would have looked like if you had never had the refunded expense at all.

I've encountered some complex cases where our software does not make the correct distinction on some refunds because it's only programmed to look for very specific things; it would probably require a general AI to probably fully mechanize the full effects of the tax benefit rule. It's one of those things where it matters exactly why you paid or received certain money; here in Michigan, there's a Homestead Property Tax credit, and that's considered a refund of your property taxes that you might have deducted for some effect. But the tax credit is thrown onto the state tax return, where it combines with the income tax refund (or amount due). Sloppy preparers (or poor programming) may treat the entire of the tax refund as a return of income tax paid, which might give different results than treating the amount of the credit as a return of property tax paid. Or even worse (the case that I actually have to deal with), the software *always* treats it as an itemized deduction recovery if it was deducted and doesn't do the same calculation as it does when there's an income tax refund regarding whether there was any actual benefit to the deduction. And things like this are the real reason why taxes are complex to deal with and lots of people prefer to go to accountants than try to figure it all out themselves. The only tax reform that could change that is to return to an era of completely unfair tax regimes that don't take into account the situations that certain individuals might be in. In order to be fair, it has to be complex.
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:42 AM.

Send questions for Cecil Adams to: [email protected]

Send comments about this website to:

Terms of Use / Privacy Policy

Advertise on the Straight Dope!
(Your direct line to thousands of the smartest, hippest people on the planet, plus a few total dipsticks.)

Publishers - interested in subscribing to the Straight Dope?
Write to: [email protected].

Copyright 2018 STM Reader, LLC.

Copyright © 2017
Best Topics: gopher smoke bomb blame canada song old walkman headphones multicolored eye eardrum throbbing floating spoon flashpoint collateral damage arnold palmer racist brakes rust ominous quotes cornmeal ants tolling service drill tempered glass guinness blonde ratebeer in the vein is loitering illegal mannlicher pronunciation black light semen working golf carts cobweb spider web three sided war std from escort foot scab regular gun bronze vs steel melting down pennies is roulette fixed viagra cost walmart top 40 acapella swarthy skin ultraman movie 2016 bluto vs brutus giant marshmallows i'm not from havana meaning ending ebay auctions early how does birth control fail how to stop boots from squeaking on tile what is the symbol on the patriots field what time does the mail come city and county of denver parking violations what does bonded mean for a job vasectomy consultation what to expect is chorizo sausage hot how do you play baseball on a dartboard lying about health insurance on tax return non electric soldering iron ww points for baked potato what to do when you receive someone else's mail gas furnace starts then shuts off signs of late growth spurt buying a car with airbag deployed how to stop a soda bottle from exploding why am i clenching my jaw do governors have security how to reattach headliner no man who has friends is poor how long does media mail take? where can i buy gumbo file powder haircut open on sunday near me 1949 singer sewing machine manual best night gallery episodes high water table basement can you get high on sudafed how to change the date on a sent email 800mb cd-r